Trading Places* (or the Andrew Lloyd Webber Night of musical proxies and switch-ups)
Tonight I play the role of blogger, one I haven't stepped into for some time now. It is, however, the second week in a row that I'll be watching American Idol by my lonesome. Yes, I am back in Manila, but the Queen of Recap is dog-tired, fast asleep and won't be bothered to get up. Instead, I earnestly take on the daunting task of editorializing my Idol viewing experience--let alone posting an entry. Pardon me Patty, I'll dare trade places with you (this week only).
Now every year I dedicateat least one entry to American Idol. I then reserve all the pent up thoughts for Patty's comment page. I usually take my chances on Standards, Big Band, American Classics, what-have-you themed weeks, being my favorites. We're at the halfway mark this season 7, and there are still no known spoilers on such a theme's existence. In its place, we have Musicals night, make that Lord Andrew Lloyd-Webber's compositions to be exact. I'll take this seemingly allied, possible proxy, distant cousin of a genre as my cue.
Coming into this week, my sister and I had our bold predictions. David Archuleta could pull off another big bad ballad moment with "Memory", as Jason incorporates his Jack Johnson-esque stylings on "Think of Me". For Carly, time to solo a duet on "All I Ask of You", with Syesha then bringing on the drama with "You Must Love Me". And Brooke could go all-out 'genuine' with her emotions on "I don't Know How to Love Him".
Surprise, surprise, these songs were actually part of the repertoire, albeit all mixed up and jumbled, with songs, personas, stereotypes, etc. flying in all directions.
Carly Smithson led the night of switches by changing her song upon Sir Andrew's advice. She backs off from our 'safe' and predictable choice, and finds herself with "Jesus Christ Superstar". And it did work for her--she came out relaxed, looked like she seriously enjoyed herself and just let it all rip. Still, somehow I feel no symapthy for this girl, and as I've always said, couldn't care less when she gets the boot.
Syesha Mercado easily managed to give the best overall performance of the night with "One Rock and Roll Too Many" (from "Starlight Express"). I loved everything about it--despite her choosing the only song I wasn't familiar with--the apropos theatrics, the exaggerated animation, that sexy red dress, and of course the vocals. She looked confident, at home on stage, and unexpectedly extremely likeable. Clearly, the brassiness and bravado she showcased, is further proof that she is in her element when making the grand gestures as opposed to the small and intimate moments.
Those moments that Brooke White exploits to the core. And so it was potentially a good move that she took on our pick for Syesha, "You Must Love Me" (from "Evita", movie version). Notwithstanding the do-over performance booboo, somehow her shakiness and unsureness matched the story she was telling--a desperate plea for a whole lot of love from the voters. Not to worry, Brooke, VFTW (Votefortheworst.com) loves you. I just find it completely naive and forgetful of her to say that it was her first time to do that (start over a song). Anyone remember, "Every breath...every breath you take... It's a pity since Brooke connected with the song, as she usually does. She gets the song, her nerves just manage to get hold of her more.
And this time around, Jason Castro fails in both the emotional and vocal department, producing the poorest number. Though darndest hard he tried to muster a half-decent version of "Memory" (from "Cats") I couldn't get past the blatant misfit with his musical archetype--this was a song Little David could easily have breezed and riffed through. Perhaps he could have owned it, but he was too uncertain, too scared of it, like he knew the song was too big for him and he was resigned to the fact (complete with obvious gasps for air). Can't say much about this performance, except that no one should attempt to sing about the twilight years when one has hardly begun a career. Don't get me wrong, this is in no way a smear campaign of one of my favorites--just taking my newfound role of critic to heart.
With the two consistent bottom-dwellers (Syesha and Carly) stepping, no rising up this week, and the folksy, erstwhile fan darlings (Brooke and Jason) resting on shaky grounds and voices, what to make of the two men who share nothing much in common save for a name? This season has shaped up to become not so much a battle of Davids and Goliaths, as it is a tale of two Davids. The two contenders seemingly destined for a confetti-riddled, pyro-blazed, tear-soaked finale.
Now the classic plot would have David Cook rocking it out, or at the least stamping his hard-edged vocals on a song you'd least expect him to tamper with. Instead we are served something else--novel, fresh and hot-off-the-press. No, not in a convoluted, inside-out sort of way, but straight up, no-nonsense singing, as unexpected as you can get with the man who has had a penchant for switching things up over and again.
So the 'word nerd' grew up doing musical theater? And he shows he has the pipes to back it up with a controlled and haunting "Music of the Night" (from "The Phantom of the Opera"). Well, we always knew he had a voice, but he never did present it this way. Of course he's no Michael Ball or Michael Crawford, but Johnny Depp, oh yes he could! I can suddenly imagine him doing Sweeney Todd's "Epiphany" or "Johanna" (and I die!). Strangely enough, watching him didn't blow me away as much as I though it would (hyped, maybe?). Still, an excellent move on his part, and for sure the studio version will be topping the office playlist.
To rival his stiffest competition, David Archuleta goes head to head with a Phantom number in his arsenal. As Cookie does serves his song Archie-suspended note, Little David slips into Rocker David's role of musical blender/bender, with an updated version of "Think of Me". He valiantly forges on with our choice for Jason Castro, and rightfully so he does.
He stepped out of his comfort zone (agree with Paula), in more ways than one. He sang a song made for a girl (not just any kind of girl, but a diva mind you). Admittedly, that may not be too much of a stretch for the boy wonder. For once, he opted for an honest-to-goodness romantic love song, and not one of universal platonic love, or worse, the inspirational fluff that has sadly become his niche.
The arrangement, a tender, simple pop-R&B infused ballad, may seem lightweight when compared with the powerful "Music of the Night". But lest we be deceived, David A. still lets the inner diva loose with the ad-libbing and vocal curlicues tumbling throughout the melody. I staunchly disagree with Simon. Yes the song was definitely pleasant, but not all weak or forgettable. Who's to say what's memorable or not, anyway? Surely, his version will be on my player for months long after the finale.
Beyond the eye-squinting, lip-licking and yet another alleged case of forgotten lyrics, it's The Voice that keeps me hooked on D'Arch. Say what you will, at least his performances make me smile. And tonight was no exception. Defend my manok to the death, diba Jeff?
Tomorrow night, for as long as the three males are safe, I can rest easy. I somehow feel cushy about The Cook and Il Divo Archuleta, It's Jason I'm worried about (Gajima, Jason!). It would be unjust to let go of Syesha after that performance. Carly can go, for all I care. At this point, things are only as solid as Brooke's next quivering breakdown.
With that, I think I've cemented one thing, one role at the least. The role that makes me utter the words 'American' and 'Idol' every so often; that, which makes it imperative for me to download mp3s faithfully and promptly store them in the newly christened K drive; that, which makes me strictly limit OT to 11 pm on Wednesdays and Thursdays; and which keeps me inside a frenzied pop bubble.
That role of Idol addict.
And that is one role I cannot easily trade in, at least not in the next month, not until fates are decided at the Nokia Theatre.
*To Patty, Rickey and Michael Slezak, my Idol idols. I know I could never seriously trade places with you.
Now every year I dedicate
Coming into this week, my sister and I had our bold predictions. David Archuleta could pull off another big bad ballad moment with "Memory", as Jason incorporates his Jack Johnson-esque stylings on "Think of Me". For Carly, time to solo a duet on "All I Ask of You", with Syesha then bringing on the drama with "You Must Love Me". And Brooke could go all-out 'genuine' with her emotions on "I don't Know How to Love Him".
Surprise, surprise, these songs were actually part of the repertoire, albeit all mixed up and jumbled, with songs, personas, stereotypes, etc. flying in all directions.
Carly Smithson led the night of switches by changing her song upon Sir Andrew's advice. She backs off from our 'safe' and predictable choice, and finds herself with "Jesus Christ Superstar". And it did work for her--she came out relaxed, looked like she seriously enjoyed herself and just let it all rip. Still, somehow I feel no symapthy for this girl, and as I've always said, couldn't care less when she gets the boot.
Syesha Mercado easily managed to give the best overall performance of the night with "One Rock and Roll Too Many" (from "Starlight Express"). I loved everything about it--despite her choosing the only song I wasn't familiar with--the apropos theatrics, the exaggerated animation, that sexy red dress, and of course the vocals. She looked confident, at home on stage, and unexpectedly extremely likeable. Clearly, the brassiness and bravado she showcased, is further proof that she is in her element when making the grand gestures as opposed to the small and intimate moments.
Those moments that Brooke White exploits to the core. And so it was potentially a good move that she took on our pick for Syesha, "You Must Love Me" (from "Evita", movie version). Notwithstanding the do-over performance booboo, somehow her shakiness and unsureness matched the story she was telling--a desperate plea for a whole lot of love from the voters. Not to worry, Brooke, VFTW (Votefortheworst.com) loves you. I just find it completely naive and forgetful of her to say that it was her first time to do that (start over a song). Anyone remember, "Every breath...every breath you take... It's a pity since Brooke connected with the song, as she usually does. She gets the song, her nerves just manage to get hold of her more.
And this time around, Jason Castro fails in both the emotional and vocal department, producing the poorest number. Though darndest hard he tried to muster a half-decent version of "Memory" (from "Cats") I couldn't get past the blatant misfit with his musical archetype--this was a song Little David could easily have breezed and riffed through. Perhaps he could have owned it, but he was too uncertain, too scared of it, like he knew the song was too big for him and he was resigned to the fact (complete with obvious gasps for air). Can't say much about this performance, except that no one should attempt to sing about the twilight years when one has hardly begun a career. Don't get me wrong, this is in no way a smear campaign of one of my favorites--just taking my newfound role of critic to heart.
With the two consistent bottom-dwellers (Syesha and Carly) stepping, no rising up this week, and the folksy, erstwhile fan darlings (Brooke and Jason) resting on shaky grounds and voices, what to make of the two men who share nothing much in common save for a name? This season has shaped up to become not so much a battle of Davids and Goliaths, as it is a tale of two Davids. The two contenders seemingly destined for a confetti-riddled, pyro-blazed, tear-soaked finale.
Now the classic plot would have David Cook rocking it out, or at the least stamping his hard-edged vocals on a song you'd least expect him to tamper with. Instead we are served something else--novel, fresh and hot-off-the-press. No, not in a convoluted, inside-out sort of way, but straight up, no-nonsense singing, as unexpected as you can get with the man who has had a penchant for switching things up over and again.
So the 'word nerd' grew up doing musical theater? And he shows he has the pipes to back it up with a controlled and haunting "Music of the Night" (from "The Phantom of the Opera"). Well, we always knew he had a voice, but he never did present it this way. Of course he's no Michael Ball or Michael Crawford, but Johnny Depp, oh yes he could! I can suddenly imagine him doing Sweeney Todd's "Epiphany" or "Johanna" (and I die!). Strangely enough, watching him didn't blow me away as much as I though it would (hyped, maybe?). Still, an excellent move on his part, and for sure the studio version will be topping the office playlist.
To rival his stiffest competition, David Archuleta goes head to head with a Phantom number in his arsenal. As Cookie does serves his song Archie-suspended note, Little David slips into Rocker David's role of musical blender/bender, with an updated version of "Think of Me". He valiantly forges on with our choice for Jason Castro, and rightfully so he does.
He stepped out of his comfort zone (agree with Paula), in more ways than one. He sang a song made for a girl (not just any kind of girl, but a diva mind you). Admittedly, that may not be too much of a stretch for the boy wonder. For once, he opted for an honest-to-goodness romantic love song, and not one of universal platonic love, or worse, the inspirational fluff that has sadly become his niche.
The arrangement, a tender, simple pop-R&B infused ballad, may seem lightweight when compared with the powerful "Music of the Night". But lest we be deceived, David A. still lets the inner diva loose with the ad-libbing and vocal curlicues tumbling throughout the melody. I staunchly disagree with Simon. Yes the song was definitely pleasant, but not all weak or forgettable. Who's to say what's memorable or not, anyway? Surely, his version will be on my player for months long after the finale.
Beyond the eye-squinting, lip-licking and yet another alleged case of forgotten lyrics, it's The Voice that keeps me hooked on D'Arch. Say what you will, at least his performances make me smile. And tonight was no exception. Defend my manok to the death, diba Jeff?
Tomorrow night, for as long as the three males are safe, I can rest easy. I somehow feel cushy about The Cook and Il Divo Archuleta, It's Jason I'm worried about (Gajima, Jason!). It would be unjust to let go of Syesha after that performance. Carly can go, for all I care. At this point, things are only as solid as Brooke's next quivering breakdown.
With that, I think I've cemented one thing, one role at the least. The role that makes me utter the words 'American' and 'Idol' every so often; that, which makes it imperative for me to download mp3s faithfully and promptly store them in the newly christened K drive; that, which makes me strictly limit OT to 11 pm on Wednesdays and Thursdays; and which keeps me inside a frenzied pop bubble.
That role of Idol addict.
And that is one role I cannot easily trade in, at least not in the next month, not until fates are decided at the Nokia Theatre.
*To Patty, Rickey and Michael Slezak, my Idol idols. I know I could never seriously trade places with you.
